“This will keep me chopping.”
A Pumpkin Cookie is a Food item cooked in a Crock Pot. It requires 1 Pumpkin and 2 Honey (or Honeycombs), and takes 40 seconds to cook.
Using 3 Honey or Honeycombs may result in Taffy instead. Adding 1 Mandrake may result in Mandrake Soup.
Pumpkin Cookies restore the same amount of 
as Taffy, but do not decrease 
. This makes Pumpkin Cookies better to eat, while Taffy is slightly cheaper to make. Pumpkin Cookies also spoil faster and restore more 
than Taffy.
Prerequisites
- Requires:
Recipe
2×
Examples
2×
2×
2×
3×
50% chance to produce Taffy.
2×
50% chance to produce Mandrake Soup.
Usage
Trivia
- Pumpkin Cookies were added in the Insanity! update.
| Food and Edible Items | |
 Meats |
                             |
 Fishes |
                                   |
 Eggs |
       |
 Vegetables |
                                                         |
 Fruits |
                      |
 Seeds |
                               |
 Other |
                          |
 Event Food |
                              |
| Crock Pot |
                                                                                       |