Pumpkin Cookies

“It's made from a vegetable, so it's healthy.”

A Pumpkin Cookie is a Food item cooked in a Crock Pot by combining 1 Pumpkin and 2 Honey (or Honeycombs). It takes 40 seconds to cook.

Using 3 Honey or Honeycombs may result in Taffy instead. Adding 1 Mandrake may result in Mandrake Soup.

Pumpkin Cookies restore the same amount of Sanity as Taffy, but do not decrease any Health. This makes Pumpkin Cookies better to eat on their own, while Taffy is slightly cheaper to make. Pumpkin Cookies also spoil faster and restore more Hunger than Taffy.

Prerequisites[]

Requires:

Recipe[]

Examples[]

An optimal way to prepare Pumpkin Cookies

50% chance to produce Taffy.

50% chance to produce Mandrake Soup.

Usage[]

×4

Tips[]

Practically, eating a Cooked Pumpkin alongside Taffy is more beneficial than eating Pumpkin Cookies. Since a Cooked Pumpkin restores 8 , it effectively cancels Taffy's Health penalty as well as restoring some Health back, while restoring the same Hunger as Pumpkin Cookie.
With 1 Pumpkin, 3 Honey, and 1 Twig, the Player can restore a total of 5 , 62.5 , and 15 from 1 Taffy and 1 Cooked Pumpkin, compared to 3 , 47, and 15 from 1 Pumpkin Cookie and 1 Honey.
However, if your honey reserves are running very low, then Pumpkin Cookies do provide more sanity per unit of honey, 15 per two honey vs Taffy's 15 per three honey.

Trivia[]

Pumpkin Cookies were added in the Insanity! update.
During the Pig Fiesta event in the Hamlet DLC, Pumpkin Cookies take on a more festive appearance.

Food and other Edible Items view
Meats	Morsel (Cooked) • Meat (Cooked) • Monster Meat (Cooked) • Leafy Meat (Cooked) • Deerclops Eyeball • Drumstick (Fried) • Fish (Cooked) • Eel (Cooked) • Frog Legs (Cooked) • Koalefant Trunk (Steak • Winter) • Jerky (Small • Monster) • Batilisk Wing (Cooked) • Guardian's Horn (Dragoon Heart • Eye of the Tiger Shark )
Fishes	Fish (Cooked) • Eel (Cooked) (Crabbit • Dead Dogfish • Dead Swordfish • Fish Morsel (Cooked) • Dead Jellyfish (Cooked • Dried) • Limpets (Cooked) • Mussel (Cooked) • Neon Quattro (Cooked) • Pierrot Fish (Cooked) • Purple Grouper (Cooked) • Dead Rainbow Jellyfish (Cooked) • Raw Fish (Cooked) • Roe (Cooked) • Shark Fin • Tropical Fish • Wobster (Dead • Cooked) )
Monster Food	Durian (Extra Smelly) • Monster Meat (Cooked) (Dead Jellyfish (Cooked • Dried))
Mob Drops	Butter • Butterfly Wings • Egg (Cooked) • Honey • Phlegm • Tallbird Egg (Fried • Hatching) (Electric Milk • Glommer's Goop ) (Doydoy Egg (Fried) ) (Flytrap Stalk • Nectar ) (Moon Moth Wings • Royal Jelly )
Vegetables	Carrot (Roasted) • Corn (Popcorn) • Eggplant (Braised) • Foliage • Glow Berry • Lichen • Mandrake (Cooked) • Pumpkin (Hot) • Red Cap (Cooked) • Green Cap (Cooked) • Blue Cap (Cooked) • Petals (Dark) (Cactus Flesh (Cooked) • Cactus Flower ) (Seaweed (Cooked • Dried) • Sweet Potato (Cooked) ) (Aloe (Cooked) • Nettle • Radish (Cooked) • Tuber (Fried • Blooming • Fried Blooming) ) (Asparagus (Cooked) ) (Garlic (Roasted) • Kelp Fronds (Cooked • Dried) • Lesser Glow Berry • Onion (Roasted) • Pepper (Roasted) • Potato (Roasted) • Ripe Stone Fruit (Cooked) • Succulent • Toma Root (Roasted) )
Fruits	Berries (Roasted) • Dragon Fruit (Prepared) • Durian (Extra Smelly) • Pomegranate (Sliced) • Banana (Cooked) (Watermelon (Grilled) ) (Halved Coconut • Cooked Coconut • Coffee Beans (Roasted) ) (Juicy Berries (Roasted) )
Dairy	Butter (Electric Milk )
Bug	(Bean Bugs (Cooked) • Gummy Slug (Cooked) )
Crock Pot	Bacon and Eggs • Butter Muffin • Dragonpie • Fish Tacos • Fishsticks • Froggle Bunwich • Fist Full of Jam • Fruit Medley • Honey Ham • Honey Nuggets • Kabobs • Mandrake Soup • Meatballs • Meaty Stew • Monster Lasagna • Pierogi • Powdercake • Pumpkin Cookies • Ratatouille • Stuffed Eggplant • Taffy • Turkey Dinner • Unagi • Waffles • Wet Goop (Flower Salad • Guacamole • Ice Cream • Melonsicle • Spicy Chili • Trail Mix ) (Banana Pop • Bisque • California Roll • Caviar • Ceviche • Coffee • (Fresh Fruit Crepes • Monster Tartare • Mussel Bouillabaise • Sweet Potato Souffle ) • Jelly-O Pop • Wobster Bisque • Wobster Dinner • Seafood Gumbo • Shark Fin Soup • Surf 'n' Turf • Tropical Bouillabaisse ) (Asparagus Soup • Feijoada • Gummy Cake • Hard Shell Tacos • Iced Tea • Nettle Rolls • Snake Bone Soup • Spicy Vegetable Stinger • Steamed Ham Sandwich • Tea ) (Creamy Potato Purée • Fancy Spiralled Tubers • Jellybeans • Salsa Fresca • Stuffed Pepper Poppers (Asparagazpacho • Bone Bouillon • Fish Cordon Bleu • Glow Berry Mousse • Grim Galette • Hot Dragon Chili Salad • Moqueca • Puffed Potato Soufflé • Volt Goat Chaud-Froid ) )
Other	Rot • Rotten Egg • Seeds (Toasted Seeds • Crop Seeds) (Birchnut (Roasted) • Ice ) (Blubber • Brainy Matter • Bile-Covered Slop ) (Bramble Bulb • Clippings • Magic Water • Seed Pod (Cooked) ) (Lune Tree Blossom )