“That's a pretty gourd cookie!”
“Cookies!!!”
“Is tasty cookie.”
“A... cookie...”
“I HAVE FLATTENED THE SHAPE”
“Pumpkin biscuits, goody!”
“This will keep me chopping.”
“It's been eons since I had a good biscuit.”
“What a delightful recipe!”
“Baked all the life öut öf it.”
“Yum!”
“Score!”
“I've outdone myself this time.”
“I have a sweet no tooth.”
“COOKIE OR NOT COOKIE”
“Belly wants it”
“I prefer chocolate chips to chunks of pumpkin.”
“Gotta indulge sometimes, hey?”
“Real food is a bit hard on my stomach.”
“THIS THE BEST KIND OF PUM-KIN.”
–Wurt
“It's made from a vegetable, so it's healthy.”
“I can never turn down a cookie.”
A Pumpkin Cookie is a Food Item cooked in a Crock Pot by combining 1 Pumpkin and 2 Honey (or Honeycombs). It takes 40 seconds to cook and 10 Days to Spoil.
When consumed, it restores 37.5 
and 15 
.
Using 3 Honey or Honeycombs may result in Taffy instead. Adding 1 Mandrake may result in Mandrake Soup.
Pumpkin Cookies restore the same amount of Sanity as Taffy, but lose hunger over its own ingredients, restoring the same hunger as a raw or cooked pumpkin while lacking the small health boost from either.
Prerequisites[]
- Requires:
Recipe[]
Recipe
Examples[]
A recipe for Pumpkin Cookies that preserves as much hunger value as possible
50% chance to produce Taffy.
Usage[]
4×
Tips[]
- Practically, eating a Cooked Pumpkin alongside Taffy is more beneficial than eating Pumpkin Cookies. Since a Cooked Pumpkin restores 8 , it effectively cancels Taffy's Health penalty as well as restoring some Health back, while restoring more Hunger than a Pumpkin Cookie.
- With 1 Pumpkin, 3 Honey, and 1 Twig, the Player can restore a total of 5 , 62.5 , and 15 from 1 Taffy and 1 Cooked Pumpkin, compared to 3 , 47 , and 15 from 1 Pumpkin Cookie and 1 Honey.
- However, if your honey reserves are running very low, then Pumpkin Cookies do provide more sanity per unit of honey, 15 per two honey vs Taffy's 15 per three honey.
- It is inadvisable to use this recipe as a sanity source, as the sanity gain is the same as a single cooked green cap while costing at least 18.75 and 9 over its ingredients.
Trivia[]
Trivia- Pumpkin Cookies were added in the Insanity! update.
- During the Pig Fiesta event in the Hamlet DLC, Pumpkin Cookies take on a more festive appearance, resembling a fortune cookie.
Gallery[]
Gallery
Pumpkin Cookies as seen in the poster for the Insanity! update.
| Crock Pot Food | |
 Original |
                         |
 Reign of Giants |
      |
 Together |
                                        (   :           ) |
 Shipwrecked |
        ( :   ) |
 Hamlet |
          |