Talk:Maxwell (NPC)/@comment-2.68.206.171-20130704095714/@comment-24.107.7.208-20130803055450

Bad theory.

William Carter is Maxwell isn't a terrible theory on its own because there's at least a piece of circumstantial evidence for it.

Everything else is an asspull. That he was sick or owed money for example. Why is this true, as opposed to maybe it was simply that he was curious about "real magic" for example?

I can make up stuff all day out of my imagination. Having an imagination does not mean you have a good theory. And I'm sick of people who think that imagination is substitute a substitute for critical thinking.