Talk:William Carter Puzzles/@comment-174.238.225.2-20141202132900

Alright, here's my theory - So, after Maxwell realized that Charlie was almost hurt in the eighth puzzle, (this might be obvious) but he gets angry at his former self and starts scratching his name and face out of all the postcards and posters he could find. He also tried to protect Jack from finding the Codex Umbra by scratching his name out, too. I also think the Shadow Watcher is the mastermind shadow for three reasons. One: he appears over the scattered papers in the fourth puzzle. Two: he seems more anthropomorphic than the other creatures Maxwell encountered (possibly someone else corrupted by Them?). Three: if you look closely in the Lost Fragment video, he appears in several frames in the pink parts. I'm not sure how all of the characters re involved, but I think all of them needed something that Maxwell told them he could provide. Wilson wanted more knowledge to help with his experiments, and in the DLC, Webber says when he examines a Maxwell statue, "That's the guy who said he could help us." That's just my theory, reply if you disagree with something.