Talk:William Carter Puzzles/@comment-82.8.228.159-20150526222548

Maybe William Carter actually died in the train crash. Then through whatever event came back, appearing as the creepier Maxwell, with his mysterious evil book.

Could explain how the shadows took him from the picture above the fireplace and he was replaced with the image of William Carter.

... sorry if this has already been suggested, there're far too many comments to read!