Talk:Renewable resources/@comment-70.67.21.160-20130413055700/@comment-70.67.21.160-20130413234420

OP here. Is there a way to reply to replies, or do I just have to reply to the original post?

"living logs arent renewable,because trees are not renewable"  By that logic, Logs, Pinecones, and Charcoal aren't renewable either.

@Mentalistpro

Nightmare Fuel: But it's dropped by Hallucinations and Beardlings. I don't understand why a common drop wouldn't fit the definition you give. I understand why Rope wouldn't be listed, since the only way to obtain it is through refinement.

If renewable resources must be easy to obtain, why not remove Beard Hair? After all, most characters can only obtain it by killing Beardlings and it has the same percent chance to drop as a Blue Gem from a Blue Hound.

My problem is that I think this list should basically be: Items You Won't Run Out Of. I agree that the list should not include wearable items such as the Krampus Sack or Spider Hat. Unless there's some limiting factor other than rarity that I'm unaware of, I still think that Nightmare Fuel, Living Logs, Red Gems, Blue Gems, and Koalefant Trunks (Deerclops Eyeballs I guess). I think it's important to inform players that an effectively infinite supply of these items are availabe.

Thanks for adding Spider Glands. I'm glad I was able to help, even if it was a small contribution.